In a rapidly spreading discussion on Reddit, a user posed the question: “Which anime is rated too highly in your opinion?” The debate focused on identifying titles that have garnered more acclaim than they arguably deserve, leading to a lively discussion among anime enthusiasts.
The Concept of “Overrated” in Anime
The notion of an anime being “overrated” doesn’t necessarily imply that it is a bad work. For many, this term relates to series that have a significant impact on pop culture or the otaku community. According to some, it transcends the actual quality of the story, characters, animation, or overall development.
Within the Reddit thread, several users discussed the phenomenon of how certain anime can influence perceptions of a show’s quality. In some cases, heavy marketing campaigns, continuous presence on social media, and the passionate engagement of its fanbase can elevate an anime to a status that may seem unwarranted to outsiders.
Additionally, many fans note that their emotional attachment to specific anime often leads to the belief that they are rated too highly, particularly when compared to more contemporary and mainstream standards. Conversely, some works that have garnered acclaim may still face criticism for not meeting certain unrealistic expectations, which could lead to disappointment when fans watch them.
Below are some opinions from anime fans regarding series they consider overrated:
– Jujutsu Kaisen… because at times, I feel like I’m only watching for the exciting battles and not for the plot.
– Kimetsu no Yaiba and Jujutsu Kaisen have excellent animation but tend to have sad storylines.
– Monster is my personal favorite. This anime is ranked 25th in the list of the best anime of all time, but I would only give it a 4.
– Fullmetal Alchemist is an average anime that is rated too highly.
– Hunter X Hunter. I watched it until the very end, and while I can see some positive aspects, overall, I think it is rated too highly, especially regarding the BAD moments.
– I recently watched Kaguya-sama: Love is War, and I don’t understand why it is rated so highly. It’s praised for its cleverness, but I don’t see it as a standout in its genre.
– Honestly, I don’t think any show is rated too highly. Any program that generates strong opinions usually stands out in my mind.
– Yu Yu Hakusho. I don’t understand the praise it continues to receive even today. In particular, the Dark Tournament arc is where everything I dislike about the series comes to light, yet it remains beloved.
– Tower of God feels like the most overrated anime of all time. God of High School is watchable, but I don’t understand the hype.
– I might get hate for this, but Frieren has some of the most disappointing early episodes, yet it is ranked highly on MAL.
– The anime I consider overrated is Neon Genesis Evangelion or Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai.
